SH Archive Who really built Russian Saint Petersburg? Did they dig it out?

SH.org OP Username
KorbenDallas
SH.org OP Date
2018-05-06 06:05:31
SH.org Reaction Score
13
SH.org Reply Count
55

KD Archive

Not actually KorbenDallas
Trusted Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2020
Messages
687
Reaction score
383
This is like a variation of the same story, no matter where you look. Now it is the Russian City of Saint Petersburg. It actually has a pretty cool legend about how it was founded, and how it was built.

"On 16 May 1703, while looking over sparse marshlands near the mouth of the Baltic Sea that he had taken from the Swedes, Tsar Peter the Great cut two strips of turf from Hare’s Island on the Neva river, laid them in a cross and declared: “Let there be a city here.” As he spoke, an eagle appeared overhead in an auspicious omen.

Peter_the_Great_Saint_Petersberg_founder.jpg

Or at least that’s the myth of St Petersburg’s founding. In reality, Peter the Great wasn’t even there, and most likely neither was the eagle. It was a group of soldiers under the command of his friend, General Alexander Menshikov, who began building what would become the Peter and Paul Fortress on Hare’s Island in May 1703. The tsar only arrived the following month.

But although untrue, this myth perfectly encapsulates the origins of St Petersburg. Built on an inhospitable swamp at the cost of thousands of lives, it was brought into being through the iron will of Peter, who needed a warm-water port and a fortress against the Swedes. Moreover, it was to be his “window to Europe”: a new capital where Peter’s western-inspired reforms of the military, bureaucracy and national culture would take hold." - St Petersburg

* * *
In May of 1703, there supposedly was nothing but swamp where the great City of Saint Petersburg was to stand. The official version states, "The city was built by conscripted peasants from all over Russia; a number of Swedish prisoners of war were also involved in some years under the supervision of Alexander Menshikov. Tens of thousands of serfs died building the city."

Here are the alleged 1698 maps of the Saint Petersburg area.
(swamp with nothing there)
Sait-Petersburg-area-Russia-1698.jpg1698_map_saint_petersburg.jpg

Saint Petersburg map: 1716, 1717 and 1720
In 1703 Peter the Great said, "Let there be a city here."
13 years later....

Sait-Petersburg-Russia-1716.png1717_map_saint_petersburg.jpg1720spb-homann_2.jpg

Peter and Paul Fortress

To put this 13 year achievement into perspective, I will show you this one complex called Peter and "Paul Fortress". On the map it looks like an insignificant star shaped thingy.
Peter and Paul Fortress_1.jpg
Actually, I think walls only will suffice.

Peter and Paul Fortress_2.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_3.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_4.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_5.jpg
Well, and some tunnels are not gona hurt the cause here.

Peter and Paul Fortress_6.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_7.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_8.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_9.jpgPeter and Paul Fortress_10.jpg

Of course we have a bunch of buildings, and a cathedral left. Those you can see here: Peter and Paul Fortress.

Peter and Paul Fortress_plan.jpg

KD Opinion: Given the 13 year time frame, I do not believe it was possible to construct a map full of brick and mortar buildings (yes, those were exactly that). Below I will try to present my opinion as to why.

Note: First of all, there is no bashing on the 18th century Russia below. I could draw the exact same parallel to just about any other country. It's just this time we are talking about Russian Saint Petersburg.

I think that art, equipment, and coins are good indicators of the human abilities within a specific time frame. The life gets reflected through the eyes of the artist. Tools and equipment give an idea of what they are capable off. And the quality of the coins, being that there was no television, internet, etc, are also meant to reflect on the governmental identity.

Now let us see what Russian art has to offer as an insight into what everything was like in the 18th century: people, equipment, road condition, etc. The images will pertain to the 18th, and occasionally early 19th centuries. I understand that 1703 is closer to the 17th century in spirit but some benefit of a doubt would not hurt here.

To make it perfectly clear, I have no idea how those people could have built some of the structures you can see in the below paintings.

Russia_18_century_1.jpg1778_russia_1.jpg1789_russia_1.jpgRussia_18_century_3.jpg
1795_russia_1.jpg1797_russia_1.jpg1799_russia_1.jpgMoscow_19_century.jpg
1783_russia_1.jpg1718_russia_1.jpgRussia_18_century_2.jpg17_century_second_half_Russia.jpg

I think the art above says it all. Modes of transportation are normal for the time frame. Clothing looks normal. The only advanced thing in the paintings is the architecture. Science says they built all that, but did they really?

What could the construction process look like? Would we see any advanced techniques in there allowing the building process to be conducted at at great speed? I was not able to find too many images, but here is what we have.

building_saint_petersburg_russia_2.jpgbuilding_saint_petersburg_russia_1.jpgbuilding_saint_petersburg_russia_3.jpgbuilding_saint_petersburg_russia_4.jpg
Nothing really special we have, just something you would expect from the early 18th century. All attempts to find any paintings of the building construction for the 18th century Russia were unsuccessful.

But we can look into some of the claimed construction techniques used 100 years later, in 1820s. I've heard that Russian alternate history gurus took this construction process apart, and called BS on just about everything. If any Russian readers would like to fill us in, on what's going on there, please do so.

Saint Isaacs Cathedral 1820_plus_1.jpgSaint Isaacs Cathedral 1820_plus_2.jpgSaint Isaacs Cathedral 1820_plus_3.jpgSaint Isaacs Cathedral 1820_plus_4.jpgSaint Isaacs Cathedral 1820_plus_5.jpgSaint Isaacs Cathedral 1820_plus_6.jpg
With the above 19th century technique it would probably take 200 years to build what was achieved between 1703 and 1716 in Saint Petersburg. I also do not think the technique matches the structures. Appears we did not make it too far from the claimed Ancient Egyptian technique.

BuildingPyramids.jpg

Tools: Well, the woodworking tools do not really pertain to what they built. Yet, woodworking were the only tools I was able to find in google.

Tools_18_century_russia.png

Coins: Here is where we run into two distinctive quality levels. This could possibly be attributed to the Tartarian heritage, but there is enough speculation for one thread. I will just say, that this is not time damage related issue. According to my Russian acquaintance, this is an ongoing topic of discussion in Russia. Apparently some of the coins (same time frame) do not match to the Kings (Tsars), have unexplanable units of currency, and greatly differ in quality.

Level 1.

Russian_coin_1_1700_1.jpgRussian_coin_1_1722_2.pngRussian_coin_1_1722_1.pngRussian_coin_1_1725_1.jpgRussian_coin_1_1729_1.JPG

Level 2.

Russian_coin_2_1700.jpgRussian_coin_2_1700_1.pngRussian_coin_2_1704.jpgRussian_coin_2_1741.jpg
Russian_coin_2_1744.jpgRussian_coin_2_1746.pngRussian_coin_2_1755.jpgRussian_coin_2_1758.jpg

* * * * *

Engravings
I was unable to find any paintings, but here are some of the engravings covering 1714 - 1716.

Sait-Petersburg-Russia-1716_X_4.jpgSait-Petersburg-Russia-1714_1.jpgSait-Petersburg-Russia-1716_X_1.jpgSait-Petersburg-Russia-1716_X_3.jpgSait-Petersburg-Russia-1716_X_2.jpg

To even get to the point where some sort of construction would be possible, they would have to get rid of the swamps, and marshlands. Then it would be the turn of building up infrastructure (roads, bridges, docks, brick factories, etc). In 1703...

A little summary: Was it possible for Russian people of the early 18th century to build all those structures we can see on the 1716 map. Sure was, but than there would have to be something in our history we are not being told about.

I personally think the City was already there. Older maps reveal the truth.

Ptolemy_edition_1535.pngAnthony Jenkinson_1562.pngOrtelius_1570_map.pngMercator_1595_map.png
But that leaves us with two questions:

1. What is the price of our history? ... and the meaning for that matter.

2. Who and why was faking our documents similar to the below Saint Petersburg maps, created in the19th century by the same author?

1700_saint_petersburg.jpg1705_saint_petersburg.jpg1725_saint_petersburg.jpg1738_saint_petersburg.jpg
1756_saint_petersburg.jpg1777_saint_petersburg.jpg1799_saint_petersburg.jpg1840_saint_petersburg.jpg1849_saint_petersburg.jpg

Bizarre things were happening in 1703
(look at this map)
1703_map_saint_petersburg.jpg
Note: This OP was recovered from the Wayback Archive.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Broken Agate SH Archive Cathedrals: Who really built them? Buildings and Structures 4
Archive SH Archive "Renaissance" Art really made in 15th century? Unmatched 3
W SH Archive Are there really 12 months in a year? Astrophysics, Space and Earth Shape 0
KD Archive SH Archive Where was Jesus really crucified: Golgotha or Cordoba? Where was the real Jerusalem? General 0
JWW427 Versailles: What was it really? Europe 6
F The Hanseatic League - who were they really? General 15
Archive SH Archive Do we really learn from the history? (And plans of TPTB) General 3
AgentOrange5 SH Archive Did Old English Really Morph Into Modern English? Etymology and Languages 5
KD Archive SH Archive World War I: What weapons was it really fought with? Wars and Conflicts 0
Archive SH Archive The Nazca Lines and what are they really! Unmatched 0
Timeshifter SH Archive The gateway to hell on my doorstep... no really!!! General 0
KD Archive SH Archive Movie: Metropolis (1927), who was it really made by? Movies 0
Archive SH Archive Was there really a tornado storm that allegedly thwarted the British in the 1814 'Burning of Washington'? General 0
KD Archive SH Archive Fake Antiquity: this is Julius Caesar. Really? Photographic Analysis 0
Broken Agate SH Archive What are minarets really for? Buildings and Structures 0
Archive SH Archive How Fast Has Language Really Evolved? A Select Comparison of Eurasian Languages Etymology and Languages 0
KD Archive SH Archive Funeral trains, flags, mummies or when did Lincoln really die? Famous Personalities 0
KD Archive SH Archive The impossible colossal "King Bath Tub" - who really produced this monster? General 0
KD Archive SH Archive What do we really know about our history? General 0
JWW427 SH Archive The 2 Largest Forts Built During the American Civil War Buildings and Structures 2
KD Archive SH Archive Who built Boys' High School, Philadelphia Buildings and Structures 0
KD Archive SH Archive Saint Petersburg Kazan Cathedral was not built when they say it was... Buildings and Structures 0
Jim Duyer Who built the pyramid(s)? We did Buildings and Structures 25
TheAsianGuy_LOL SH Archive Brooklyn Bridge Built As Told? Buildings and Structures 0
trismegistus SH Archive Mormons (among others) built a DUMB on the 33rd Parallel Buildings and Structures 2
Archive SH Archive Exploring An Abandoned Former Boarding School Built late 1800s Buildings and Structures 0
Archive SH Archive Who built the Cathedral of Las Lajas, Colombia Buildings and Structures 0
KD Archive SH Archive Alacanti (Tibi) Dam built in Spain between 1579 and 1594 Buildings and Structures 0
KD Archive SH Archive Who built Stadium High School in Tacoma, WA? Buildings and Structures 0
KD Archive SH Archive Similar style buildings are all over the world. Were they built by our civilization? Buildings and Structures 1
KD Archive SH Archive Who built Holy Names Academy building in Seattle? Buildings and Structures 0
Silveryou Hidden History: Russian past in the Middle East. Famous Personalities 9
JWW427 Russian Alien Races Book Aliens and UFO's 1
D Can any of our Russian members shed light on this miniature sarcophagus? Help 4
Z 250 years ago there was no Russian language yet General 22
Z An extra millennium in the Russian archives Calendars and Grand Cycles 4
Z Sinkholes in Dedilovo village, Tula region, Russian Federation General 2
Petrenko Descendants of Julius Caesar Octavian Augustus - rulers of the Old Russian kingdom General 8
KD Archive SH Archive Meaning: 1800 Russian Greater coat of arms... Symbology 0
Fanna 'Beerit' - Some Russian Manual (the casting of marble) Patents and Inventions 0
Timeshifter SH Archive One-legged skeleton found under Russian dance floor is Napoleon's 'lost general', Charles Etienne Gudin Famous Personalities 0
KD Archive SH Archive 19th century: Russian Cast Iron Road Buildings and Structures 0
Archive SH Archive Russian troll factory General 0
KD Archive SH Archive Single photo: 1896 Russian Windmill. All Russia Exhibition. Photographic Analysis 0
Archive SH Archive Palace of Farmers, Ministry of Agriculture, Tartarstan, Russian Federation Buildings and Structures 0
KD Archive SH Archive 1873: Russian Round Armored Ships of Admiral Popov General 0
KD Archive SH Archive USA Anthem vs. Old Russian Song Music and Songs 0
KD Archive SH Archive 1863 Russian involvement in the US Civil War Wars and Conflicts 0
KD Archive SH Archive Single etching: 1662 Russian Tsar meeting an embassy from the Austrian emperor Leopold I Photographic Analysis 0
KD Archive SH Archive 1932 Russian Steel Balls Train General 0

Similar threads

Users who are viewing this thread

Top