Suggestions For The Forum

[Deleted member 1432]

OK, I understand. Thank you.

 

[Deleted member 1432]

Sometimes it's very difficult to choose a thread title that encompasses the entire content of a single post, as often significant snippets that have wider implications are part of the OP.

I remember 'tags' were fashionable at one time, but it also brings up an association to those awful Twatter hashtag things. Is there any other system available that would enable the highlighting of significant themes associated with a post, but not specifically mentioned in the title?

 

[dreamtime]

Sometimes it's very difficult to choose a thread title that encompasses the entire content of a single post, as often significant snippets that have wider implications are part of the OP.

I remember 'tags' were fashionable at one time, but it also brings up an association to those awful Twatter hashtag things. Is there any other system available that would enable the highlighting of significant themes associated with a post, but not specifically mentioned in the title?

There's actually a tag system for threads, and it can be configured in a way that only the OP can chose tags. Clicking on a tag would then show all threads tagged with the specific keyword, I believe. I have never looked into this system.

 

[Deleted member 1432]

There's actually a tag system for threads, and it can be configured in a way that only the OP can chose tags. Clicking on a tag would then show all threads tagged with the specific keyword, I believe. I have never looked into this system.

Sounds interesting... I suppose there's the danger that all posts will get tagged #tartaria [joke]

 

[Deleted member 1432]

There's actually a tag system for threads, and it can be configured in a way that only the OP can chose tags. Clicking on a tag would then show all threads tagged with the specific keyword, I believe. I have never looked into this system.

Actually, thinking about it this may not be that useful given the vast number of pre-existing threads that have no chance of ever being 'tagged'.

Perhaps a simpler solution would be to list any additional 'juicy-bits' that are not evident from the title in the post's introduction. In that way it would show up in the preview when the title is hovered-over in the 'What's New' etc. lists.

In relation to that: is it possible to create a link to a specific section or word of an OP that can be used from within the OP itself... does that make sense? It would be, for example, like a list of contents at the beginning of the post with each entry linking to that section of the OP when clicked. A sort of short-cut for those who might only be interested in certain parts of a post for the purpose of their own research, for example.

 

[trismegistus]

A sort of short-cut for those who might only be interested in certain parts of a post for the purpose of their own research, for example.

I generally find the search function fairly helpful for that, insofar as keywords. I use it all the time.

You can also bookmark posts yourself for quick reference.

 

[dreamtime]

In relation to that: is it possible to create a link to a specific section or word of an OP that can be used from within the OP itself... does that make sense? It would be, for example, like a list of contents at the beginning of the post with each entry linking to that section of the OP when clicked. A sort of short-cut for those who might only be interested in certain parts of a post for the purpose of their own research, for example.

I actually discussed that on the old forum, but unfortunately there is no such feature yet. I had in mind a way to turn the forum into a better collaboration tool - basically you would be able to create a reference/tag for a specific sentence or paragraph and then it would automatically turn into a new thread (or a sub-thread), linked from that sentence - it would over time create a cross-referenced web on the forum where people could follow such 'breadcrumbs' of interlinking discussions.

 

[Deleted member 1432]

I actually discussed that on the old forum, but unfortunately there is no such feature yet. I had in mind a way to turn the forum into a better collaboration tool - basically you would be able to create a reference/tag for a specific sentence or paragraph and then it would automatically turn into a new thread (or a sub-thread), linked from that sentence - it would over time create a cross-referenced web on the forum where people could follow such 'breadcrumbs' of interlinking discussions.

That would be great, just what I was thinking of in fact.

@trismegistus 's suggestion of using the Search facility may work for what I was asking about, but I would need to try it out - unless he can confirm that it definitely works. It would need to be done retrospectively after the post has been published, but before the editing opportunity expires. I'll try it when I get round to posting something again.

Edit: It doesn't work. The link generated by searching for specific text within an OP only sends you to the OP in general, not the specific text within it... There must be some html code that can be used?

Would this be useful?
https://www.w3docs.com/snippets/htm...ink-to-jump-to-a-specific-part-of-a-page.html

 

[Sasyexa]

random threads

Or like wikipedia, have a hotkey to take you to a random article

 

[davtash]

I prefer to read hard copy and print when I can but a lot of time it doesn't print all. Is there a way threads could be made in book form and maybe sold as a subscription? Maybe not all threads but selected in advance by subscribing members. Maybe produced by someone who is paid?

 

[Deleted member 1432]

Would it be possible to activate the following BBCODE tag?

[a=anchorname]value[/a] - which allows the assignment of an 'anchor' that could be linked to from within the same post.

Thanking you in anticipation.

 

[davtash]

I prefer to read hard copy and print when I can
but a lot of time it doesn't print all. I enjoy reading David Ewing JR'S books also printed. Is there a way threads could be iijmade in book form and maybe sold as a subscription?pp Maybe not all threads but selected in advance by subscribing members. Maybe produced by someone who is paid?

 

[Deleted member 1432]

I prefer to read hard copy and print when I can but a lot of time it doesn't print all. I enjoy reading David Ewing JR'S books also printed. Is there a way threads could be made in book form and maybe sold as a subscription? Maybe not all threads but selected in advance by subscribing members. Maybe produced by someone who is paid?

Wouldn't there be copyright issues?

 

[Referent]

Given the desire to encourage more history discussion in the many history topics and threads we have, I would suggest the idea of making the "home page" of "stolenhistory.net - Rediscovered History of the World" automatically go to the "Forum list" page, which lists all the different sections and exposes way more threads. I think I would browse more broadly if there were one less click to the actual Forums page, since more subjects are linked there.

I admit it is my own stubborn and lazy fault, but, for some reason, my main habit is to always type in stolenhistory.net, scan the Latest Threads and Latest Posts for anything interesting. I know the answer is to use a bookmark or copy-paste in or type the correct link, so, please, don't bother educating me on solutions.

Anyway, I wonder if the same "problem" might happen to "afflict" many other users, too. That is why I post this. Maybe an admin could tell based on traffic patterns. If so, I would suggest the change, to encourage broader history diving. Not a big deal to me, take it or leave it! An idea though.

I tried searching and did not see this suggestion already, but could have missed it. (I assume it is set up the way it is for a reason.)

 

[luddite]

Would it be possible to activate the following BBCODE tag?

[a=anchorname]value[/a] - which allows the assignment of an 'anchor' that could be linked to from within the same post.

Thanking you in anticipation.

Sorry missed this one. Let me get back to you.

 

[mifletzet]

'The Moderation' section states "Where do we intervene?.......You will receive a direct message with an explanation."

I have started several threads that I though were quite interesting that did not stay up eg "Tartarian anomalies in the Age of Sail: 1600-1850".

One does not receive this 'direct message' nor response to queries from the Moderators. Are the Moderators too busy? In the pursuit of novel human knowledge it would be of avail to get a response.

 

[dreamtime]

'The Moderation' section states "Where do we intervene?.......You will receive a direct message with an explanation."

I have started several threads that I though were quite interesting that did not stay up eg "Tartarian anomalies in the Age of Sail: 1600-1850".

One does not receive this 'direct message' nor response to queries from the Moderators. Are the Moderators too busy? In the pursuit of novel human knowledge it would be of avail to get a response.

You mean this probably: Moderation

It was no longer up to date and I have removed the parts that are no longer relevant.

Thread is here now, apologies: 'Tartarian' anomalies in the Age of Sail 1600-1850:? All that wood!

Your other unapproved threads where quite spammy and without much substance, so it likely slipped through.

 

[Whitewave]

Would it be possible to make a thread listing all the maps that have been posted on this site (maybe with a note of which thread they were posted for reference)?
Whenever I'm looking for a particular map I can never remember what thread I saw it in which leads to hours of searching, usually with frustrating results and no map found.
Thank you.

 

[trismegistus]

Would it be possible to make a thread listing all the maps that have been posted on this site (maybe with a note of which thread they were posted for reference)?
Whenever I'm looking for a particular map I can never remember what thread I saw it in which leads to hours of searching, usually with frustrating results and no map found.
Thank you.

Hey Whitewave glad to see a post from you!

Unfortunately I don't think there would be to automate this, only way I could see that coming about is someone would have to manually compile all of those map images and create a new thread. Only other way I could see this working would be to individually upload each map to the library with a title that would make it searchable, though that would lead to a ton of extra threads in the library.

I can't say that I would have the time to do something like this, but if someone wanted to take up the project it would surely be a much appreciated and valued part of the site!